One look worn two ways

I wanted to do something holiday-ish.  So I went for silver (with glitter, which you can totally not see at all!) with red lips.  And then me, being SUPER uncomfortable in red lips decided to change them to pink.  And I took pictures just to show what a big difference a lip color can make.

The eye makeup:

What I used:

TFSI (as always!)

NYX JEP (so I had something for my pigment to stick to)

NYX Ultra Pearl Mania "Silver" foiled on lid

NYX Ultra Pearl Mania "Silver" not foiled above crease and under eye

NYX "Black" shadow along lashline and in outer v

Balmbini Volume 2 "Promiscuous Pearl" as highlight

L'oreal HIP Color Chrome Eyeliner "Black Shock" (may I just say holy burning eyeballs!!  Don't put this on your waterline!)

L'oreal Voluminous Carbon Black mascara

Some false lashes I had hanging out

 Now on to the full face pictures!

Now I realize that it looks like I changed more than just my lip color when I went from red to pink.  But all I did was add just a bit more blush (I looked too washed out without it).  The lighting outside changed in between the time I got done with the red and the time I got the pink on.

Red lip colors:

NYX Soft matte lip cream "Amsterdam"

NYX Electra

NYX Snow White

I used a bit of all of these because I couldn't get it to look right

Pink lip colors:

The light pink Lipthix from Calypso Minerals

MAC "Right Image" Cremesheen Glass

Face makeup:

Revlon Colorstay for Oily/Combination skin

(in the colors "Buff" and "Sand Beige" mixed together)

Maybelline Dark Circle treatment in Fair

Maybelling Super Stay concealer (the second lightest color)

Covergirl Professional loose powder in translucent fair

ELF studio blush/bronzer duo (LOVE this bad boy!)

Balmbini Volume 2 "Promiscuous Pearl" for a highlight

And with the pink lip I added some of Ulta's "Girlie" blush

Which look do you like better?  Which one would you wear?  I know for myself, I really tend to like the look of red lips, just not on me haha.  I don't know what it is but still, I feel like people are staring at me with the red lips.  I feel like the red lips are much more Christmas-y though.

Thank you all so much for checking this out!!  

And if you haven't yet, be sure to enter my Calypso Minerals giveaway!!